behavior will decrease through this process. Consistency and of the aversive are crucial. Also, the stimulus must be from the human if the goal is to suppress the behavior . In other words, the dog needs to learn that something bad happens when he tries to get in the trash there. Those who haven’t studied behavior science don’t have the information to plan this out. And it takes a System response, rather than the knee-jerk, System 1 response, to make that plan. I’m not condoning punishment, planned or unplanned; I’m just saying that often when people think they are punishing behavior.